(RNS) — I’m afraid my closing column, which instructed that our most popular pronoun for God be “they,” disillusioned some people. Offended emojis outnumber satisfied ones 4-1 at the RNS response app, and the damaging retweets are legion.
“I assumed it was once all meant to be about the most well liked pronouns of the person involved, no longer the pronouns that the ones round would favor to have them identified,” wrote one commenter. “I believe God has made His most popular pronouns completely widely recognized right through the divinely impressed Scripture.”
“God has already advised us his most popular pronouns,” wrote any other. “That is about as simple as imaginable.”
For the reason that Biblical Hebrew is the language by which the God of Abraham, Isaac and Jacob conveyed their presumed pronoun personal tastes, those retorts are harking back to the commentary, most often attributed to Texas Governor “Ma” Ferguson, “If the King’s English was once excellent sufficient for Jesus Christ, it’s excellent sufficient for the youngsters of Texas!”
However the shift from singular (“he”) to plural (“they”) is not anything new in addressing the Maximum Prime. Within the Hebrew Bible, God is addressed with the second-person masculine pronoun “‘attah.” Previous English (Anglo-Saxon) and, later, Center English, didn’t differentiate pronouns via gender however did, like Hebrew, have other singular and plural second-person paperwork. Particularly, the Center English singular “thou-thee-thy” and plural “ye-you-your.”
Between the 14th and seventeenth centuries, then again, the plural paperwork “you” and “your” changed “thou and thy” (alongside the strains of the French vous), bringing with them the plural verb shape “are” rather than the singular “artwork.” That’s to mention, “you’re” — the plural shape — changed the singular “thou artwork.” Sooner or later the English-speaking global was pleased with addressing God with the as soon as completely plural “you.”
A equivalent procedure seems to be underway as “they’re” replaces “he’s” and “she is” within the third-person singular. I’m ready to wager that God is not more bummed about this newest alternate than they have been concerning the transfer from “thou” to “you.”
In fact it’s going to take many people some time to regulate to having to discuss with any and all beings as “they” — and in all probability particularly relating to the Deity. The King James translation of the Bible, first revealed in 1611, nonetheless employs Thou-Thee-Thy when addressing God, although those have been neatly on their manner out of abnormal utilization.
Lots of my commenters have made it transparent that they see my proposal as a rejection of all male phrases for God — section and parcel of the feminist critique that has been underway a minimum of for the reason that overdue theologian Mary Daly revealed their influential “Past God the Father” in 1973.
Nevertheless it’s usual Christian theology that God isn’t a gendered being. As early because the 4th century, the Cappadocian Father St. Gregory of Nazianzus contended that “Father” and “Son” within the Trinity are supposed to be understood as metaphors. The present Catholic Catechism teaches the similar even because it refers to God with the normal masculine third-person singular pronoun.
By no means is God in guy’s symbol. He’s neither guy nor girl. God is natural spirit by which there’s no position for the adaptation between the sexes. However the respective “perfections” of guy and girl replicate one thing of the endless perfection of God: the ones of a mom and the ones of a father and husband. (pg. 370)
This theological place is expressed within the want of many Jews and Christians to keep away from calling God “he.” The evolution of the English third-person singular to “they” is helping them do this.
Nevertheless it does no longer save you any English speaker hooked up to singular male metaphors like father, husband and king from proceeding to make use of them — not more than the evolution to “you” did centuries in the past.