Why are Christians so divided? Psychology provides us some solutions – and options

Why are Christians so divided? Psychology provides us some solutions – and options

(Photo: Getty/iStock)

Division within the church has been an issue since its earliest days. There are detailed Biblical accounts of rows over theology, preferences for preachers, deciding what’s moral behaviour, and extra.

Two explanations are sometimes given for our disunity. Firstly, reality: that the church should cut up when a basic doctrine of our religion is at risk. And secondly, sin: that human beings are naturally disposed to disagree and argue, and so sadly our imperfect world will at all times have an imperfect, divided church.

Yet, Jesus prayed for us to be united (John 17:21-23). So we should always discover our divisions to know them and deal with them, wherever attainable. While secular psychology is usually not seen as a Christian’s pal, it has produced some fascinating analysis into how and why human beings divide with one another. It’s worthwhile exploring whether or not these divisive forces in our psyche are additionally at work within the physique of Christ.

Social psychologist Christena Cleveland determined to do that in her fascinating e book: “Disunity in Christ: uncovering the hidden forces that keep us apart” (Inter-Varsity Press). She acknowledges that as a liberal, city-dwelling Christian, she has her personal biases towards sure “Wrong Christians”. The entire e book is nicely value a learn, particularly for her work on cross-cultural relations.

Here’s some psychological insights into why we divide:

It may be onerous work to cope with “distinction”

Humans are inclined to desire the simpler route. We may be biased towards a bunch of individuals if it is more durable to know them as a result of they’re completely different from us.

To cope with this more durable work, we frequently put individuals in “packing containers”

Our brains are unconsciously a bit lazy, so that they categorise individuals in order that we do not have to work too onerous to know them as a person, particularly if they seem to be a bit completely different. But this may result in creating small and arbitrary labels akin to “Arminian”, “liberal,” “preppy” or “West Coast”, and making generalisations about them which are solely partly true, or not truthful in any respect.

We unconsciously desire the individuals we establish with – our “ingroup”

There has been a variety of analysis on ingroup/outgroup bias. We are way more forgiving, caring, and optimistic in the direction of individuals who we think about our “ingroup”. This may be primarily based on unchangeable components like race, gender or nationality, but in addition chosen traits like trend, soccer staff or faith. As nicely as being biased towards them, we are inclined to see “outgroups” as all the identical – the flowery identify for that is the “outgroup homogeneity impact” – although like every group of individuals, there may be a variety of selection between people.

Ingroup/outgroup bias could make us need to be completely different, even after we’re not

Even if we’re very comparable, division itself could make us deal with tiny variations between “us” and “them”. Christena provides an instance of two “hipster” church buildings close to one another. Although they’ve the identical nice graphic design, worship type, younger pastors and fair-trade coffee, individuals emphasise slight variations akin to whether or not one pastor is extra good-looking than the opposite church, after which says “we’re nothing like them!” If divisive forces are at work between two very comparable church buildings, what does it imply for church buildings which are fairly completely different, akin to Pentecostals and Calvinists?

Group identification boosts our vanity

We are inclined to need to have a look at the positives of our “ingroup”, as a result of it helps to bolster our personal vanity, often known as “basking in mirrored glory”. In experiments by the writer, if a bunch had executed nicely on a activity, it will extra intently establish with that group. If it had executed badly, they might distance themselves from it. Sadly this does imply that people typically select to criticise an outgroup, simply to really feel higher about themselves.

We are biased to assume we’re the very best

The “gold normal impact” is a psychological bias that makes us (typically, wrongly) assume that our personal method of doing issues is the very best. Otherwise referred to as pleasure, I suppose.

We even have self-serving biases that may be proven throughout experiments, and so we fee our personal private efficiency extra extremely than we should always do. The mixture of things enhances division, in keeping with Christena:

“By considering extremely of ourselves, we naturally assume much less of others. There could be social issues on the earth, however our group will not be accountable for them. That different group is the reason for all the ills. There could be friction inside our local people of Christians, however we’re harmless. The downside could be solved If the opposite church would vote otherwise, or get severe about dwelling the Christian life, or get their theology straight. They want us, however since we’re excellent, we do not want them.”

So what can we do to scale back division and overcome our unhealthy psychology?

There’s loads of religious options, akin to prayer and making use of Scripture to our lives. But psychology provides fascinating insights, too:


One method that experiments have proven we may be much less divisive is that if we’re conscious of the biases we have now, and work to intentionally problem them. Ask God to disclose them, being conscious that a lot of them are unconscious, simply the way in which our brains are wired.

Consider yourselves half of a bigger group

That may be the entire international church, and even simply the human race. Even utilizing the phrase “we” to explain all human beings might help. Look on the church as the worldwide physique of Christ. That contains Christians who’re very completely different in musical style, tradition and apply.

Concentrate on what unites us, not what divides us

Another is to deal with the similarities between your ingroup and an outgroup, quite than the variations. Experiments discovered that when individuals consider these shared traits, they fee an outgroup extra positively. Focusing on the widespread love of Jesus that each one Christians share, for instance.

Practice empathy

Another useful software is to assume what it’s like within the different particular person’s sneakers – or “perspective taking”.

Spend extra time with people who find themselves completely different from us

Go to completely different church buildings and spend time in several cultures and nations – lengthy sufficient to get to know individuals there. When we study to establish with people who find themselves completely different to us, we’re much less prone to deal with them as an “outgroup”.

Know we’re every cherished by God and apply self-affirmation

Experiments on “self-affirmation idea” present that we’re much less inclined to place different individuals down and/or be defensive about our ‘ingroup’, if we be ok with ourselves. Knowing who we’re in Christ, a cherished youngster of God, is a a lot better method to be ok with ourselves.

Have a typical aim

Work on a co-operative challenge along with a unique church and/or denomination. Working in the direction of a bigger aim helps to interrupt down divisions. As the world round us turns into extra divided, it is as much as us to study to develop into peacemakers, each inside and outdoors the church.



Express your views here

Disqus Shortname not set. Please check settings



5 Cannes Film Festival 2023 Premieres To Keep An Eye On

5 Cannes Film Festival 2023 Premieres To Keep An Eye On