NEW YORK (AP) — The Vatican has concluded that allegations of sexual abuse relationship again a part century in opposition to the Roman Catholic Bishop of Brooklyn don’t “have the appearance of reality,” however an legal professional for the accusers mentioned they’d press ahead with their civil instances.
Cardinal Timothy Dolan, the Archbishop of New York, mentioned Wednesday that the Vatican has closed its investigation into allegations made one at a time by means of two males, who accused the bishop, Nicholas DiMarzio, of abusing them a part century in the past when he used to be a clergyman in New Jersey.
DiMarzio denied the accusations made by means of his accusers, either one of whom have filed civil claims in opposition to him.
“I repeat what I’ve mentioned from the start. There’s no reality to those allegations. During my greater than 50-year ministry as a clergyman, I’ve by no means abused any individual,” DiMarzio mentioned in a remark. He mentioned he “totally cooperated” with the investigation.
“I stay curious about main the Diocese of Brooklyn as we’re rising from the darkness of the Coronavirus pandemic,” he mentioned. “I ask in your prayers as I proceed to combat in opposition to the complaints stemming from those two allegations, and as I now stay up for clearing my title within the New Jersey state courts.”
The Vatican’s dealing with of the case used to be being intently watched as it used to be some of the first to return beneath new procedures installed position two years in the past by means of Pope Francis to handle allegations of sexual abuse in opposition to one of the most church’s easiest rating clergy.
Critics, together with the legal professional for his accusers, expressed worry that the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Religion, created from different bishops, would lack impartiality.
“The investigations regarding the credibility of my purchasers have been subjective and biased for the reason that investigators have been managed by means of and paid for by means of the Catholic Church,” mentioned the lads’s legal professional, Mitchell Garabedian.
“The Congregation of the Doctrine of the Religion, which rendered the verdict, is within the industry of continuous the secrecy of clergy sexual abuse by means of hiding the reality,” Garabedian asserted.
Certainly one of his accusers, Samier Tadros, mentioned the abuse started when he used to be 6 years outdated and a parishioner at Holy Rosary Church in Jersey Town.
Tadros, who’s now 48, has demanded $20 million in reimbursement.
The Related Press does now not normally determine sufferers of sexual abuse except they arrive ahead publicly, as Tadros has achieved.
In accordance with the allegations, Dolan employed a regulation company to behavior an investigation. That inquiry used to be led by means of former FBI Director Louis Freeh.
The findings have been then forwarded to the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Religion for its evaluation, which made up our minds that the accusations have been baseless.
The Survivors Community of the ones Abused by means of Monks, extra repeatedly referred to as SNAP, mentioned it used to be now not shocked by means of the Vatican’s movements and prompt New York Legal professional Normal Letitia James to behavior its personal investigation.
“Given Bishop DiMarzio’s prime rank within the Catholic Church — and particularly given the truth that he have been tapped by means of Vatican leaders to research different prelates accused of wrongdoing — we imagine true transparency and duty will want to come from secular officers in New York and New Jersey, now not Rome,” SNAP mentioned in a remark.
The Legal professional Normal’s Workplace didn’t have instant remark.
Anne Barrett Doyle, the co-director of BishopAccountability.org, a Boston-based team that has accumulated an infinite on-line archive of paperwork and stories alleging sexual wrongdoing by means of Catholic clergy, puzzled the Catholic Church’s transparency within the subject and referred to as at the Church to unlock all paperwork associated with its investigation.
“Despite the fact that their investigation used to be thorough,” she mentioned, “simplest Cardinal Dolan had the facility to filter out and interpret the proof sooner than sending” it to the Vatican.
Given the findings of the Vatican frame, Dolan mentioned in his announcement, it “is not going to authorize to any extent further canonical procedure to handle the accusations.”